This is from my grandmother's cookbook (or perhaps my great grandmother's) circa 1920. I never saw the cookbook, but am blessed to have the recipe. I've not had vegetable beef soup that tasted like this. I always thought it had noodles when I was a boy, but that was the cabbage.This is mostly true to the original, the most significant difference of which the addition of the barley. But well, I like barley.
Add Beef, Water, and salt to a dutch oven. Cover and bring to a boil
1 lb Beef shank, 3½ c Cold Water, 1 T Salt
Skim, recover, and simmer 4 hours
Remove bone
Add remaining ingredients except for parsley. Cover and simmer 30 minutes
1 Garlic clove, ½ c Onion, 1½ t Salt, 1/8 t Pepper, 1 c Green beans, ¾ c Celery, ⅔ c Peas, ½ Cabbage (Small), 1 c Carrots, 1 28 oz can Tomatoes, ¼ lb Pearl Barley